Why Experts Need Checklists: Busting Myths About Skill and Memory

The Limits of Expertise

Expertise is invaluable, but it does not make one infallible. Human memory and attention have natural limits that no amount of training can fully overcome. In complex environments, even experts forget steps or miss details.

Studies show that ICU patients require hundreds of care actions daily, and errors occur despite the best efforts of professionals. This is not a failure of skill but a reflection of cognitive overload.

Why Checklists Help

Checklists serve as external memory aids, reducing reliance on fallible human recall. They provide a clear framework that supports judgment rather than replacing it, allowing experts to focus on nuanced decisions.

Far from diminishing professionalism, using checklists demonstrates humility and commitment to safety. It acknowledges that no one can do it all alone and that collective tools and teamwork are essential.

Changing Mindsets

Overcoming resistance to checklists requires shifting cultural attitudes. Professionals need to see checklists as enablers of excellence rather than constraints. Leadership, education, and evidence of success help drive this change.

Embracing checklists is a step toward safer, more reliable performance in any field.

Sources: 1 , 3