Why Keto Doesn’t Always Work for Women: The Hormonal Truth Behind Fat Loss
Unpacking the surprising reasons why ketogenic diets may backfire for many women and how to fix it.
Ketogenic diets, characterized by very low carbohydrate intake and high fat consumption, have proven effective for many men. However, women often experience paradoxical effects — weight gain, fatigue, mood swings, and disrupted menstrual cycles.
Understanding Women’s Hormonal Needs
Women require more carbohydrates than men to maintain thyroid function and regulate cortisol, the body’s primary stress hormone. When carb intake drops too low, cortisol can spike, impairing fat loss and causing hormonal chaos. Additionally, women store fat differently, mostly subcutaneously, which affects how their bodies respond to fat-burning diets.
The Research Gap and Its Consequences
Most keto studies focus on male subjects, leaving women underrepresented. This gender bias has led to incomplete dietary guidelines that fail to address women’s unique metabolic and hormonal landscapes.
How to Modify Keto for Women
Dr. Gottfried’s approach involves increasing non-starchy vegetables and moderate carbohydrates, maintaining a 2:1 fat to protein+carb ratio instead of the classic 4:1. This modification helps stabilize cortisol and supports thyroid health, preventing common keto pitfalls.
Supporting Hormones Through Lifestyle
In addition to diet, managing stress, optimizing sleep, and incorporating intermittent fasting carefully can improve hormonal outcomes. Exercise that includes resistance training and HIIT supports muscle mass and testosterone production.
Conclusion: Personalization is Key
Women’s bodies are not one-size-fits-all. Understanding and respecting hormonal needs is essential for effective fat loss and overall health. By tailoring ketogenic diets and lifestyle habits, women can overcome the keto paradox and thrive.
Sources: Goop, Melioguide, Amazon 4 3 1
Want to explore more insights from this book?
Read the full book summary