Psychology

Noise: A Flaw in Human Judgment

Name: Noise: A Flaw in Human Judgment
Rating: 4.8 (1000 reviews)
Author: Daniel Kahneman, Olivier Sibony, Cass R. Sunstein

Daniel Kahneman, Olivier Sibony, Cass R. Sunstein

27 minAudio9 insights

What you'll learn

•The distinction between bias and noise as components of judgment error.
•How to measure noise and bias using noise audits and error equations.
•Psychological mechanisms that produce noise and bias in human judgment.
•The superiority of mechanical predictions and algorithms over human judgment.
•Practical decision hygiene strategies to reduce noise in organizations.
•The trade-offs between rules and standards in managing noise and discretion.
•The ethical and social implications of noise reduction, including dignity and fairness.

Who should read this

✓Leaders and managers seeking to improve organizational decision making
✓Professionals in fields requiring complex judgments such as law and medicine
✓Policy makers interested in fairness and accuracy in public decisions
✓Data scientists and AI practitioners working on decision support systems

About this book

An insightful examination of noise in human judgment, its impact on decision-making, and practical strategies to reduce it for fairer and more accurate outcomes.

Did You Know?

“

The concept of noise in judgment was largely overlooked until this book brought it to widespread attention.

Audio Summary

Section 1

The Hidden World of Noise: Understanding the Invisible Flaw in Our Judgments

3:45

9 Sections

Preview: The Hidden World of Noise: Understanding the Invisible Flaw in Our Judgments

Imagine a world where decisions about your fate, your health, or your livelihood depend not only on facts but also on an invisible cloud of randomness. This is the world shaped by noise—the silent, unpredictable variability in human judgment. Unlike bias, which pushes all decisions consistently in one direction, noise scatters judgments widely around the target, like a shooter whose bullets fall erratically around the bull’s-eye.

Noise is everywhere, yet it often goes unnoticed because we assume that professionals who share expertise and information should agree more than they do. Consider the case of four teams shooting at a target. One team’s shots cluster tightly around the bull’s-eye, representing accurate and consistent judgments. Another team’s shots are all off to one side, showing bias—systematic error. But two other teams’ shots are scattered, some close, some far, with no consistent pattern—this is noise, the unpredictable disagreement that undermines fairness.

Real-world examples abound: in courts, two defendants with similar crimes may receive wildly different sentences depending on which judge they get. In medicine, doctors often disagree on diagnoses even when presented with the same patient data. In insurance, underwriters quote premiums that differ by over 50% for identical cases. And in asylum hearings, applicants’ chances of success can vary from 5% to 88% based on the assigned judge. This variability is not just inconvenient; it is a form of injustice and inefficiency.

Why does this happen? Because human judgment is inherently noisy. People differ in their experiences, moods, interpretations, and momentary states. Even the same person may judge differently on different occasions due to subtle factors like fatigue, weather, or recent events. This noise accumulates, creating a lottery-like system where outcomes depend partly on chance.

Recognizing noise is the first step toward improving decisions. Unlike bias, which has been widely studied and acknowledged, noise remains a hidden flaw. Yet it is just as damaging, causing unfairness and economic loss. Organizations often operate under the illusion of agreement, unaware of the magnitude of noise within their ranks.

Understanding noise sets the stage for exploring how to measure it, analyze its sources, and ultimately reduce it through deliberate practices and tools. As we move forward, we will delve deeper into the science of noise, its psychological roots, and practical methods to bring clarity and fairness back to human judgment.

Let us now turn to how noise can be measured and decomposed, revealing the anatomy of this invisible foe.